Tuesday, August 4, 2020

Update On WWE Physician Dr. Amann’s Lawsuit Against CM Punk & Colt Cabana

There are some new developments in WWE’s Dr. Chris Amann’s lawsuit against former WWE Superstars CM Punk (Phil Brooks) and Colt Cabana (Scott Colton) stemming from comments made on the infamous “Art of Wrestling” podcast episode from November 2014.

To recap, Amann’s claim is that Punk & Cabana made statements about him on the podcast that were untrue and defamatory by improperly insinuating he lacked integrity and competence as a medical doctor. Specifically, Amann claims that Punk sullied his reputation by claiming Amann misdiagnosed a lump on his back as simply a ‘fatty deposit’ and ignored his requests to remove it, a deposit that Punk went on to claim ended up turning into life-threatening MRSA.

- Advertisement -

Amann denies Punk asked him to treat or remove a lump or anything off of his back, denies he examined Punk nor did he prescribe him any antibiotics. Amann also says Cabana aided in falsely depicting him as a lazy and/or incompetent doctor. His position is that both men knowingly fabricated the false and disparaging statements about him and is seeking in excess of $1 million in compensatory and punitive damages.

In the closing months of 2015, the two sides were going back and forth addressing the plaintiff’s attempts to squash Punk and Cabana’s defense pleadings. The court had ruled that some of the defense’s claims were inadmissible, which led to Punk and Cabana’s defense responding to the lawsuit with amended responses on December 15th.

In this filing, Punk argued that his comments on the podcast were his opinion and therefore should fall under the First Amendment of the Constitution (Free Speech). Additionally, he argued that his statements were “substantially true” – doubling down on his claim that Amann neglected to drain the lump on his lower back Punk and failed to diagnose it as a “potential MRSA or staph infection.” This is the most assertive Punk has been during the course of the lawsuit in identifying Dr. Amann by name as the person who he alleges provided him with reckless medical care.

Punk also alleged that he suffered “severe head trauma” in the Royal Rumble match (Punk’s final WWE match), but “Plaintiff did not direct or encourage [Punk] to leave the ring” and that “Plaintiff had indicated [that Punk] had discretion as to whether to remain in the ring.”

Amann alleges in his lawsuit that his privacy was violated on the “Art of Wrestling” podcast, but in the 12/15 filing, Punk’s camp responded that Amann was a public figure as a result of his job with WWE (including appearances on TV, on WWE.com, etc.) and the statements made about him on the podcast are fair game as a result.

The defense is pushing for a jury trial to determine the fate of the lawsuit. The next hearing is scheduled for February 1st.

Credit to Mike Johnson of PWInsider.com and our own David Bixenspan for assistance with the facts related to the December 15th filing.

Trending Articles

Chaos At Today’s WWE TV Tapings, Shane McMahon Returning for RAW

WWE has announced that Shane McMahon will return on tonight's RAW episode. McMahon has been off WWE TV since losing the Career vs. Career Ladder...

WWE RAW Results (8/3): Shane McMahon Returns, Dominik Attacks Rollins

WWE RAW aired from the Performance Center in Orlando. Shane McMahon made his return tonight to debut RAW Underground and Randy Orton...

Shane McMahon Returns To Reveal RAW Underground

Shane McMahon returned to WWE television Monday night to introduce RAW Underground. The son of WWE Chairman & CEO...

Two Former WWE Stars Debut During AEW’s Women’s Tag Team Cup Tournament

AEW's Women's Tag Team Cup Tournament kicked off tonight on the company's YouTube channel and it saw the debut of not one...

Eric Young Says That Triple H Did Not Know About His WWE Release

Eric Young was one of the guys Triple H had signed to NXT. He found success in the development territory of the...

Latest Wrestling News

Impact Signs Kimber Lee To Contract

Kimber Lee is now officially a member of the Impact roster. She has been performing on recent shows since the promotion began...

Impact Wrestling Emergence: 2-Week Special Event Announced

Impact Wrestling has announced Emergence, a 2-week event that will air on AXS TV later this month. These...

Sonya Deville On Advice She Gave To Tegan Nox

Smackdown's Sonya Deville recently took part in an interview with the International Business Times. During the interview, Deville revealed that Tegan Nox...

Arn Anderson Comments On Women’s Wrestling In 2010

Arn Anderson was working backstage in WWE in 2010. He recently spent some time talking with Conrad Thompson about the Money in...

Eric Bischoff On Moving To Stamford For WWE

Eric Bischoff was the Executive Director of WWE Smackdown from the summer of 2019 until March of 2020. He moved to Stamford,...

Gallows & Anderson Trying to Lure AJ Styles Back To Impact Wrestling

Former WWE Superstars Karl Anderson and Luke Gallows have made it clear: they want to see AJ Styles back in Impact Wrestling....

WWE Superstars Offer Nikki & Brie Bella Parenting Advice

Several WWE Superstars have recorded their congratulations for Brie and Nikki Bella following the births of their newborn sons. The Bella Twins...

Eric Bischoff On RAW’s Declining Viewership, Dynamite’s Recovery During COVID-19

Former SmackDown Executive Director and WCW President Eric Bischoff has commented on RAW's declining viewership. Speaking with Chris Featherstone of Sportskeeda, Bischoff...

Luke Gallows & Karl Anderson Discuss Impact’s Influx Of Former WWE Superstars

Former WWE Superstars Luke Gallows and Karl Anderson have previously spoken about their decision to become a part of Impact Wrestling's roster....

Chris Jericho Considered Retirement In 2015, Shares Future Retirement Plans

Chris Jericho has spoken about his future retirement plans during a recent episode of his YouTube show, Saturday Night Special. During the episode,...

Eric Young Says That Triple H Did Not Know About His WWE Release

Eric Young was one of the guys Triple H had signed to NXT. He found success in the development territory of the...

Austin Theory Reportedly On An “Unannounced Suspension”

Former NXT star Austin Theory hasn't been seen on WWE programming for a while now and latest updates on the situation suggest...